Love and loathe are strong words, but let's indulge in a little hyperbole while I discuss something I like and something that has driven me to my wit's end. I had high hopes for both Smashbox's Santigolden Age palette in Apocolypse Now and Bobbi Brown's gel liner in Cobalt Ink, but which is the living end and which product's failure to perform was a personal insult?
The Love: Smashbox's recent release in collaboration with Santigold is a collection of brightly coloured Aztec-inspired palettes, pencils and lip glosses. I picked up the eyeshadow palette in Apocolyse Now because who needs another neutral palette, am I right?
The shadows are incredibly pigmented, and although they are daring colours, they can be blended out to a sheer wash of shimmer. The black is particularly smooth and pigmented - easily the best black eyeshadow I've encountered. I was hesitant that the shimmery golden orange, despite its beauty, would be of little use to me, but it is perfect to add a little warmth to the outer v and, used lightly, is really more of a warm gold. My only gripe is that the pinky champagne shade which comprises the right snake eye is so small.
The Loathe: I was in need of a new navy gel eyeliner recently. Now, I could have gone to MAC - I have a few fluidlines and I like them - but I thought, "No, you can do better than MAC." Everyone is always banging on about Bobbi Brown's long wearing gel liner so I googled some swatches of Cobalt Ink and decided that was the one for me.
The colour is a beautiful rich matte navy. That's the only redeeming feature of this liner. It is so dry. So. Dry. It's impossible to get a smooth line. It is nigh on impossible to create a smooth, clean line and when I tried to go over the line to even it out it completely flaked off. I've tried different brushes, I tried warming up the product, I tried spraying my brush with a little Fix +; nothing. The catastrophic failure of this liner after the positive reviews I read is like a betrayal. It's maddening - is it just me, or is it truly woeful?
My search for a navy gel liner continues...